The Battle of Arnhem: The Deadliest Airborne Operation of World War II by Antony Beevor
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

The Battle of Arnhem is the latest book from Antony Beevor. This covers not just the battle for Arnhem involving the British 1st Airborne Division, but also the rest of Operation Market-Garden. This is a very detailed look at the entire operation, and provides a wealth of information about the operation and where it went wrong. It is very compelling story, of poor planning, wishful thinking and the courage of ordinary soldiers. Beevor continues the story beyond the battle and we learn what happened to the Dutch civilian population during the “hunger winter” of 1944-45.

If anything, there is perhaps too much detail. It is sometimes hard to follow the narrative as we jump from one unit to another, or one sector of the battle to another.

I do like the book, but I think it suffers somewhat in comparison to A Bridge Too Far by Cornelius Ryan. Though the Ryan book is fairly old at this point and new sources and information have come to light since it was published in 1974, it does have a very good narrative that helps the reader place people and events in their proper context.

Heads You Win by Jeffrey Archer
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

I have mixed emotions about this novel by Jeffrey Archer. On the one hand it is an interesting concept; a young man and his mother flee Leningrad at the height of Cold War, and it’s a matter of chance where they wind up – the United States or the UK. On the other hand, it’s kind of sloppily written, so it does not exactly compel you to finish reading it. But the advantage is that you can put the book down and pick it up days later without really losing your place.

The structure of the novel is that it alternates between the two options available to the Karpenkos on the docks of Leningrad. We follow the parallel stories of Sasha Karpenko in Great Britain and Alex Karpenko in New York. It’s an interesting concept and it serves the author’s purpose fairly well, except for the occasional editing error. If you separate out the stories, this is vintage Archer: lots of local color, many characters and the cameos by historical figures. But there are also odd leaps in both stories that are not adequately explained, and despite all of the exposition in the early going, the conclusion to both stories seems rushed.

The novel is entertaining but clearly it’s not Archer’s best work. Many of his earlier book, such as First Among Equals, are much better in terms of the storytelling.

Hue 1968: A Turning Point of the American War in Vietnam by Mark Bowden
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

Hue 1968 is the story of the battle for the city of Hue during the Tet Offensive of 1968. The Tet Offensive began on the morning of January 31, 1968 with a series of attacks by the National Liberation Front across South Vietnam. The attack on Hue was main focus of the offensive, and within hours most of the city had fallen to the NLF. It would take nearly a month of hard fighting for the American and South Vietnamese forces to retake the city.

The author covers all sides of the battle, and it is a very interesting story. It is clear that the NLF expected to win a military victory, because they expected that the civilian population would rise up, not just in Hue but in South Vietnam. This did not happen. On the American side, senior commanders refused to believe that the NLF could appear in force and capture a major city like Hue. This disbelief lead to the commitment of the Marines to the battle for the city in a piecemeal fashion with tragic consequences for the Marines. Indeed it seems that until nearly the end of the battle, no American officer at the division level or above really had any idea of the size of the force their units were facing.

The author also covers the stories of the civilians who were trapped in the city during the fighting. Many civilians were killed during the fighting, some of whom were executed by the NLF because of their ties to the South Vietnamese government. It is difficult to estimate the number of civilian deaths.

Militarily speaking, Hue was a defeat for the NLF. But as Clausewitz reminds us, “War is merely the continuation of politics by other means.” For over a year, American officials in Saigon and Washington had been talking about how well the war had been going and how the North Vietnamese and Viet Cong forces were nearly spent. The Tet Offensive, and in particular the battle for Hue, showed that they were completely wrong. And once this became widely apparent, the American political will to continue the Vietnam War began to diminish. So Tet was in some sense a strategic victory of the NLF. And it truly was a turning point in the war.

It’s a long book and it’s not an easy read, but in my opinion it is the definitive book on the battle for Hue. Using primary and archival sources, the author is able to tell a compelling story of what happened in Hue in 1968, and why it mattered.

The Fifth Risk by Michael Lewis
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

The Fifth Risk is a set of true stories about the parts of the Federal government and some of the people who work for it. It is also the story of the transition between the Obama and Trump administrations. I found the book to be fascinating as it explains about the work done by the Department of Energy, the Department of Agriculture and the Department of Commerce, especially NOAA. Very interesting stuff – some of the things that these departments are responsible for are surprising. Well, surprising to me at least.

One constant thread through the stories is the apparent failure of the Trump transition team to take the transition seriously. I won’t go into any details because of potential spoilers, though if you keep up with current events there is nothing here that would surprise you.

The author does a good job of telling the stories; I’ve enjoyed several of his previous works. I really enjoy his writing style. I recommend this book – it’s definitely worth reading if you are interested in politics or government.

Munich by Robert Harris
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

Munich is another historical thriller from Robert Harris. The setting is the Munich Conference of 1938 at which Germany, Italy, France and the United Kingdom agreed that Czechoslovakia must give up the Sudetenland to Nazi Germany. It’s an important event in the build up towards World War 2, but it’s also something that is fairly well known, and I was curious as to how the author would approach it, and what kind of story he could create with this setting.

The first part of the book a little slow, but we meet two diplomats, one British and one German, who were friends at Oxford. We follow their stories in parallel as the crisis unfolds and eventually they meet again in Munich where each is a junior staff member of his respective delegation. There’s not much more that I can say without getting into spoilers.

The author has used some of the more recent historical research on Prime Minister Chamberlin. It’s always been easy, in retrospect, to condemn his policy of appeasement, but could Great Britain have gone to war in 1938 over the Sudetenland and been victorious? It’s not a simple question.

The Oster resistance group is also part of the novel. There was a plot among some officers in the German Army to arrest and depose Hitler if he tried to invade Czechoslovakia. How realistic this conspiracy was, and it’s actual chance of success are both debatable.

So with the constraints of history, he doesn’t really have a lot of room to maneuver, I think Mr. Harris has done a good job of story telling. I found the book to be a good read; yes it is a little slow in the first part of the book, but the twists and turns in the stories of the two protagonists kept me interested until the end. I recommend this book.

Introverts in the Church: Finding Our Place in an Extroverted Culture by Adam S. McHugh
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

This book covers a very interesting topic. Given that the Church must be outward facing to accomplish its mission, how do introverts fit into the Church?

The author, an introvert himself, provides compelling evidence that a typical Christian Church is primarily set up to appeal to extroverts, even though introverts make up about half of the population. This can be tremendously off-putting to an introvert who is seeking to find a church where he or she feels comfortable. Or consider an introverted person who feels the need to become an ordained minister; how does he or she lead a congregation?

The author has a number of ideas that can make a church more appealing to introverts and also has suggestions, some of which are based on his own experience, about how an introverted pastor can successfully lead a congregation.

As an introvert myself, I found the book to be quite interesting. I think that some of the author’s analysis can be applied to extroverted organizations, other than the Church. All in all, it’s a very interesting and thought-provoking book.

The Last Man Who Knew Everything: The Life and Times of Enrico Fermi, Father of the Nuclear Age by David N. Schwartz
My rating: 5 of 5 stars

The Last Man Who Knew Everything is an outstanding biography of Enrico Fermi. Beginning with his birth in 1901, the author takes us through Fermi’s personal and professional lives, his education and career, the decision to emigrate to the United States, his involvement with the Manhattan Project, etc. The flow of the narrative makes it a very pleasant and informative read.

To me, one of the joys of this book is that it explains Fermi’s contributions to physics – beta decay and the weak force, slow neutron capture and fission, nuclear chain reactions, pion-proton scattering, etc – without ever resorting to equations. That is quite an accomplishment given the breadth of Fermi’s accomplishments.

Enrico Fermi was one of the true giants of 20th Century physics. He was a fascinating man and this biography allows us to examine his life and his legacy. I highly recommend this book!

Louis: The French Prince Who Invaded England by Catherine Hanley
My rating: 5 of 5 stars

Louis is a biography of Louis VIII of France, who was the son of Philip II Augustus and father of Louis IX. Louis was King of France for only a very short period of time, approximately three years, so he is probably remembered mostly for his invasion of England in 1216, which is not particularly well-known either.

Briefly, and there are some spoilers here, when the barons rose in revolt against King John after he revoked the Magna Carta, they offered the throne to Louis. Louis accepted the offer and invaded England, where he and the barons rapidly gained control of most of the country. However, King John died unexpectedly, and there was considerable sympathy for his 9 year old son and heir, Henry III. There were some opportunities that Louis missed, but the timing of John’s death was obviously out of his control. Eventually Louis reached a settlement with William the Marshall who led Henry’s forces.

Though he controlled England for a year or so, Louis is not really considered a king of England. It is a fascinating story and the author has done a great job of bringing the story to life. Louis is a relatively obscure figure, but he played an important part in the history of both France and England. I highly recommend this book.

Target Tokyo: Jimmy Doolittle and the Raid That Avenged Pearl Harbor by James M. Scott
My rating: 5 of 5 stars

Target Tokyo tells the story of the Doolittle Raid on Japan in April 1942. There have been many books on this subject, but this one is different in that it does not focus solely on the raid and the 80 men who flew the B-25s. The story begins with Pearl Harbor, and the beginning of the idea of the raid as a way to strike back at Japan. We also learn about the fears of some of the high ranking Japanese generals and admirals that Japan was not well protected against an air attack. And from here the story unfolds with the selection of the aircraft and the training of the flight crews to be able to take off from an aircraft carrier and fly their bombers to Japan and then on to the unoccupied regions of China.

One of the very interesting things to me, was that during the narrative of the actual bombing mission, we learned not only what the flight crews did, but also where their bombs landed and what damage was caused by the raid, including civilian deaths and injuries.

There is much more to the book: the aftermath of the raid for the 15 crews that made it to China and the one the landed in the Soviet Union, the public relations battle between Tokyo and Washington over the raid, which was complicated by the American authorities not getting prompt notification of the success of the raid, even though all of the planes were lost. And there are stories of the raiders who died in China and those who were captured by the Japanese, some of whom were liberated at the end of the war. But the most heartbreaking part of the book is the story of the Japanese offensive into those areas of China were the raiders landed. The Chinese civilian casualties were enormous.

It is a compelling story, and the author has made the most of some new primary sources of information and so is able to paint a more complete picture of the raid and the aftermath. I recommend this book very highly; if you are interested in the complete story of the Doolittle Raid, this is the book for you.

Great Tales from English History, Vol 3 by Robert Lacey
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

This was the third and final volume of the Great Tales from English History series. This volume covers the period from the Glorious Revolution of 1688 to the 1950s. Like the previous volumes, this one consists of a series of short stories from the history of England, well, actually Great Britain in this case. The stories are in chronological order, but they are not necessarily very tightly coupled into a narrative. So it’s an easy book to read, and you can set it down for a few days and then pick it up again without any problems.

I enjoyed this book, and the entire series, and I recommend them to anyone who is interested in English history. It’s a very gentle introduction to the subject, and a fun and easy read.